4/11/1980 — Preliminary Round (G3), 4-3 L vs. Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Yvon Lambert (0:29)*
4/9/1986 — Division Semifinal (G1), 3-2 W at Quebec Nordiques
Game-Winning Goal: Sylvain Turgeon (2:36)
4/23/1986 — Division Final (G4), 2-1 W vs. Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Kevin Dineen (1:06)
4/29/1986 — Division Final (G7), 2-1 L at Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Claude Lemieux (5:55)*
4/8/1987 — Division Semifinal (G1), 3-2 W vs. Quebec Nordiques
Game-Winning Goal: Paul MacDermid (2:20)
4/16/1987 —  Division Semifinal (G6), 5-4 (L) at Quebec Nordiques
Game-Winning Goal: Peter Stastny (6:05)
4/8/1989 — Division Semifinal (G3), 5-4 L vs. Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Stephane Richer (5:01)
4/9/1989 — Division Semifinal (G4), 4-3 L vs. Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Ross Courtnall (15:12)*
4/15/1990 — Division Semifinal (G6), 3-2 W vs. Boston Bruins
Game-Winning Goal: Kevin Dineen (12:30)
4/29/1992 — Division Semifinal (G6), 2-1 W vs. Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Yvon Corriveau (0:24)
5/1/1992 — Division Semifinal (G7), 3-2 L at Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Russ Courtnall (25:26)*
4/24/1999 — Conference Quarterfinal (G2), 3-2 W vs. Boston Bruins
Game-Winning Goal: Ray Sheppard (17:05)
4/30/1999 — Conference Quarterfinal (G5), 4-3 L vs. Boston Bruins
Game-Winning Goal: Anson Carter (34:45)
4/18/2001 — Conference Quarterfinal (G4), 3-2 W vs. New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Rod Brind’Amour (0:46)
4/19/2002 — Conference Quarterfinal (G2), 2-1 W vs. New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Bates Battaglia (15:26)
4/24/2002 — Conference Quarterfinal (G5), 3-2 W vs. New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Josef Vasicek (8:16)
5/7/2002 — Conference Semifinal (G3), 2-1 L at Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Donald Audette (2:26)
5/9/2002 — Conference Semifinal (G4), 4-3 W at Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Niclas Wallin (3:14)
5/19/2002 — Conference Final (G2), 2-1 W vs. Toronto Maple Leafs
Game-Winning Goal: Niclas Wallin (13:42)
5/21/2002 — Conference Final (G3), 2-1 W at Toronto Maple Leafs
Game-Winning Goal: Jeff O’Neill (6:01)
5/28/2002 — Conference Final (G6), 2-1 W at Toronto Maple Leafs
Game-Winning Goal: Martin Gelinas (8:05)*
6/4/2002 — Stanley Cup Final (G1), 3-2 W at Detroit Red Wings
Game-Winning Goal: Ron Francis (0:58)
6/8/2002 — Stanley Cup Final (G3), 3-2 L vs. Detroit Red Wings
Game-Winning Goal: Igor Larionov (54:47)
4/24/2006 — Conference Quarterfinal (G2), 6-5 L vs. Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Michael Ryder (22:32)
4/26/2006 — Conference Quarterfinal (G3), 2-1 W at Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Eric Staal (3:38)
5/2/2006 — Conference Quarterfinal (G6), 2-1 W at Montreal Canadiens
Game-Winning Goal: Cory Stillman (1:19)*
5/8/2006 — Conference Semifinal (G2), 3-2 W vs. New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Niclas Wallin (3:09)
5/28/2006 — Conference Final (G5), 4-3 W vs. Buffalo Sabres
Game-Winning Goal: Cory Stillman (8:46)
5/30/2006 — Conference Final (G6), 2-1 L at Buffalo Sabres
Game-Winning Goal: Daniel Briere (4:22)
6/14/2006 — Stanley Cup Final (G5), 4-3 L vs. Edmonton Oilers
Game-Winning Goal: Fernando Pisani (3:31)
4/17/2009 — Conference Quarterfinal (G2), 2-1 W at New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Tim Gleason (2:40)
4/19/2009 — Conference Quarterfinal (G3), 3-2 L vs. New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Travis Zajac (4:58)
5/6/2009 — Conference Semifinal (G3), 3-2 W vs. Boston Bruins
Game-Winning Goal: Jussi Jokinen (2:48)
5/14/2009 — Conference Semifinal (G7), 3-2 W at Boston Bruins
Game-Winning Goal: Scott Walker (18:46)*
4/13/2019 — First Round (G2), 4-3 L at Washington Capitals
Game-Winning Goal: Brooks Orpik (1:48)
4/24/2019 — First Round (G7), 4-3 W at Washington Capitals
Game-Winning Goal: Brock McGinn (31:05)*
4/26/2019 — Second Round (G1), 1-0 W at New York Islanders
Game-Winning Goal: Jordan Staal (4:04)
8/12/2020 — First Round (G1), 4-3 L at Boston Bruins
Game-Winning Goal: Patrice Bergeron (21:13)
5/21/2021 — First Round (G3), 5-4 L at Nashville Predators
Game-Winning Goal: Matt Duchene (34:54)
5/23/2021 — First Round (G4), 4-3 L at Nashville Predators
Game-Winning Goal: Luke Kunin (36:10)
5/25/2021 — First Round (G5), 3-2 W vs. Nashville Predators
Game-Winning Goal: Jordan Staal (2:03)
5/27/2021 — First Round (G6), 4-3 W at Nashville Predators
Game-Winning Goal: Sebastian Aho (1:06)*
6/3/2021 — Second Round (G3), 3-2 W at Tampa Bay Lightning
Game-Winning Goal: Jordan Staal (5:57)
5/18/2022 — Second Round (G1), 2-1 W vs. New York Rangers
Game-Winning Goal: Ian Cole (3:12)
4/19/2023 — First Round (G2), 4-3 W vs. New York Islanders
Game-Winning Goal: Jesper Fast (5:03)
4/28/2023 — First Round (G6), 2-1 W at New York Islanders
Game-Winning Goal: Paul Stastny (6:00)*
5/11/2023 — Second Round (G5), 3-2 W vs. New Jersey Devils
Game-Winning Goal: Jesper Fast (7:09)*
5/18/2023 — Conference Final (G1), 3-2 L vs. Florida Panthers
Game-Winning Goal: Matthew Tkachuk (79:47)^
5/20/2023 — Conference Final (G2), 2-1 L vs. Florida Panthers
Game-Winning Goal: Matthew Tkachuk (1:51)

* — series-clinching goal
^ — longest game in franchise history

Most career playoff overtime goals for Hartford/Carolina: 3 (Jordan Staal and Niclas Wallin)
Most career playoff overtime goals against Hartford/Carolina: 2 (Russ Courtnall, MTL, and Matthew Tkachuk, FLA)